I love playing in a woodwind quintet, but one of my other passions is, believe it or not, the guitar. It may surprise you to know that I prefer electric guitar over acoustic. I think it’s because it’s a complete change from the instrument I play while “at work”. I love turning up the volume on my amp, plugging in a couple of effects pedals and enjoying the rich variety of tones and effects that are possible on the electric guitar.
The subject of whether electric or acoustic guitars are better is hotly debated by guitar players the world over. There is no right or wrong answer to this; you should go with what your heart and ears tell you, rather than paying attention to other people’s opinions on which is the better instrument, whatever reasons they offer. Over the years I’ve noticed that there are 3 main reasons that are commonly given for making the switch from acoustic to electric. They are valid reasons and, if you’re thinking of buying your first guitar, they might help you make up your mind which way to go.

Photo by Yuri Samoilov
Reason 1
A lot of people start out their playing careers as children and are encouraged to play by their parents or teachers. The general direction that parents want to push their kids in is away from rebellious rockstar types and towards the more serious and socially acceptable classical guitar. It’s considered more high brow and intellectual.
When these kids hit their teenage years, however, rebellion is exactly what they want from their music so they very often switch to electric so they can make more noise and turn their amps up to eleven.
Reason 2
Some people have smaller hands and can find the demands of successfully holding down an F Chord on an acoustic guitar something of an effort. This can be very frustrating because they will be trying to spread their fingers across the wider neck of the acoustic and, with fingers at full stretch, it is much harder to apply string pressure (that’s if they can reach at all).
In addition to the wider necks that many acoustic guitars have, if they are steel-strung and have a high action this can make things almost impossible. The thick steel acoustic guitar strings typically have a higher tension than nylon strings or their thinner counterparts on the electric guitar, which increases the power required to hold down the strings against the frets. The higher action simply means there is further to push the strings to press them against the frets. All very hard work and for some people, no matter how hard they work on their guitar exercises, they might never get as good as they would like. Life can be so much easier on an electric guitar with narrow gauge strings and a low action.
Reason 3
Richness of tones
If you’re at all interested in varying the tones produced by your guitar, and some types of music demand this, then an electric wins out over an acoustic any day.
Acoustics are limited to producing the traditional sound amplified by the hollow body and the only variations that can be achieved are from changing how hard you strum or pick the strings, or by applying simple and relatively subtle techniques like palm muting or playing harmonics.
On the other hand, an electric guitar has no end of possibilities. You can vary the volume between zero and impossibly loud with the twist of a knob. You can apply any number of effects using the settings on your amp, many of which come with distortion and reverb as standard. But if you really want to go to town you can plug in an effects pedal (or pedals) or even plug your jack into your PC or a purpose built effects box. With these gadgets you can create wah wah effects, phaser, distortion, reverb, chorus, sustain…the list is endless. For a creative musician, these sounds provide a superb palette for generating interesting multi-layered sounds that add tremendous depth to their songs.
So, if you’re a rebel at heart, struggle with the more challenging chord shapes, or simply want to spread your creative wings, I can highly recommend making the switch from acoustic to electric.
Of course you can play both, and many people do. Whatever suits the mood I say. But whatever you choose, remember this: consistent, methodical practice is what all the great guitarists have in common. So set aside time every day for at least a short practice session. The improvements compound on each other and are well worth the effort.